Versão em Português

Virgilio Vasconcelos

Virgilio Vasconcelos' keywords: Copyleft; Research; Debian; Heterotopias; Donna Haraway; UFMG; Privacy; Diversity; Rigging; Michel Foucault; Krita; Bernard Stiegler; Punk Rock; Open Access; OpenToonz; Perspectivism; Blender; LUCA School of Arts; Python; Free Software; Digital Arts; Digital Animation; Art; Gilbert Simondon; Noam Chomsky; Fedora; Decolonial thinking; GNU/Linux; Democracy; Ailton Krenak; David Graeber; Jacques Derrida; Re:Anima; Remix; Education; Pierre Bourdieu; Cosmotechnics; Gilles Deleuze; Technics; Ubuntu; Animation; Paulo Freire; Re-existence.

About

I'm an Animation Professor at LUCA School of Arts, campus C-mine in Genk, Belgium. I teach at the Re:Anima Joint Master in Animation and I'm a senior researcher at the Inter-Actions Research Unit. My research interests include philosophy of Technics, power relations inscribed in and reinforced by technical objects, and decolonial perspectives in animation. Previously, I was an Animation Professor at Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais (UFMG), in Brazil. MFA and PhD by the Graduate Program in Arts at EBA/UFMG. I'm also a free software advocate, animator, rigger and I also like to code. You can see some of my works and know a bit more about me at:

ORCID LUCA School of Arts/KU Leuven LinkedIn YouTube



Blender Animation Book

I've written a book about Rigging and Animation in Blender for Packt Publishing. You can get the files here.

Old Blog

Yes, I had a blog. Haven't updated it since 2011. Anyway, if you need something from there I have kept backwards compatibility and you can read it below.

Haven't watched Transformers 2 yet, but I will some of these days.

The production of a blockbuster movie like this is usually:

1 - Very hard to do;

2 - VERY expensive;

3 - Demands some time to achieve.

I've read an article at Gizmodo which tells how "only" 40 frames (little less than two seconds) took three months to be created by five skilled artists at Digital Domain. The Computer Graphics Supervisor, Paul George Palop, said this process was "very, very painful".

By this facts I wonder if the holy Triangle of Production rule was broken with this particular shot.

Director Michael Bay is known for demanding everything to be "awesome". So, putting movie making and script aside (we're talking only about technical achievements here), the final result is awesome.

Considering that and the Triangle rule, now we have only one option left to pick: that shot have to be cheap or quick to make.

Let's see... the production budget was - at least - 200 million dollars. That is so much money that the producers hired a top notch studio like Digital Domain to make the "secondary" effects and animation, since the main ones were made by ILM. Thinking of that we can assume it wasn't cheap (even more if we consider the current financial world crisis).

So... all it's left is to be quick and the rule works like a charm, right?

In my humble opinion: wrong.

After all, five artists working full time for three months to complete 40 frames does seem to be a fairly long time to me.

I have no doubts that these are among the best professionals working on animation and effects, and they've done a huge amount of top notch work as quick as they could. They have obviously reached the "awesome" vertex of the triangle.

Since they've got "awesome" and it was apparently not quick, the only variable that can "fix" the rule is Digital Domain not earning a good amount of money to make that shot. Probably not...

Rule broken?

[UPDATE] You can read more on the production details of this scene at CGTalk [/UPDATE]

Talking about Michael Bay:

(2) Comments

10/Jul/2009
chimericdol said:

Hey Virgilio,

The rule has not been broken. It was cheap and fast... so not awsome. And thats true, I mean ok, the effects are amazing but movie in general was not so good.


10/Jul/2009
Virgilio said:

Hi, chimericdol

Yeah... I really don't expect the movie to be good. After all, Bay is not Kubrick... That's one reason I didn't bother to buy a ticket to watch it ;)

But I meant the triangle for the actual production of the movie (whether it is bad or good).

The effects seem to be pretty good and expensive (not everyone can hire Digital Domain).

3 months to complete 40 frames looks like a long time, but I might be wrong on this feeling because I'm not used to this kind of production...

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! :)